Icelandic Rides

It may as well be another planet

My first ever true international trip (besides Canada and Mexico) was to Australia in 2005.  I first noticed that Nissan Skylines were nearly as common as the Mercedes S-class stateside.  I knew that only a small part of the world automotive output was sold here and my week in Reykjavik reinforced that idea even more.

20181214_062449

I already did a thorough review of our tiny Hyundai i10 rental.  When purchasing an i10, the 3 main deciding factors are price, price, and price.  It’s one of the least expensive new cars sold nationwide, but will still set you back about US$19,000.  If you’re only use for a car is with minimal cargo and passengers and to go from point A to point B, it fits the bill just fine.

20181208_052022

Would you want this intimidating truck barreling down on you with all those lights on?  I thought it looked near apocalyptic, but it was much smaller than the typical 18-wheeler in the states.  I would have like to ask the driver/owner what the Indiana placard meant.

20181214_064343

Electric cars are slowing catching on in the US, but they are EVERYWHERE in Iceland.  Since gas runs about (gulp) US$6.60 per gallon and electricity is abundant and super cheap due to geothermal plants all over, it’s the perfect place for the Nissan Leaf, Chevy Volt, and this C-Class Benz just to name a few.  This exact model Benz C350e is sold here in the states, but I have yet to see one on the road.

20181214_043020

This Mitsubishi Outlander PHEV is also sold in the USA, but I can’t remember ever seeing one at the dealership that’s barely 1000 feet from my house, much less one on the road.  These were by far the most common SUV in Iceland and Mitsubishi has been reporting much higher sales in all of Europe for 2018.  Stateside, the Mi-EV is more common.  Go figure.

20181208_065352

Wagons are nearly as popular in Iceland as SUVs are here domestically.  The only Honda branded wagon I can think of in the past 20+ years is the upscale Acura TSX wagon.  I loved this Accord wagon that slightly resembles a compressed Honda Odyssey.  Without even verifying the mileage estimates, I’m confident it is substantially higher than the CR-V and Pilot.  Stateside, we were cursed with the hideous Honda Accord CrossTour from 2010 to 2015.  Again, go figure!

honda-civic-tourer-2014-1viaautomoto.it
photo courtesy via bing

We were trailing a Civic Wagon for a bit, but I couldn’t get a clear picture since it was near sunset, but with this internet photo you get the idea it’s not the commonplace hatchback version sold here.   I’m curious if gas was $6+ per gallon in the USA, would people largely abandon SUVs and move back to wagons?

20181213_090226

Along the same lines as wagons, the Skoda Fabia is referred to as a family car.  It reminds me of a domestic Dodge Journey.

20181212_091242

One of my favorite rides in Iceland was the Skoda Octavia Estate.  The ‘wagon’ version of the Octavia outnumbered the sedan version an easy 10 to 1.  The Skoda hasn’t been sold in the USA since the 1950’s.  Volkswagen (Skoda’s parent company since 1991) is debating a return to domestic U.S. sales, but I’ll believe it when I see it.

20181213_081439

This Peugeot 207 wagon was older, but since no one has seen a new Peugeot stateside since 1991, the distinctive lion logo stands out.

20181213_092711

The Renault Scenic looks similar in size to our rental Hyundai, but it is actually in the same class as the BMW X2.  For this size vehicle, it has very unusual 20″ wheels optional.

20181214_063004

in the same size class as the Scenic, this little oddity is the Citroen C4 Cactus.  I’m not sure what the design staff was going for with the soundproof looking material on the doors, but this has got to be one of the most unmistakable rides in the world.

20181207_070603

This darker C4 Cactus is a little less polarizing.  Citroen hasn’t sold a new car in the USA since 1974.

20181214_062904

Another Citroen oddity, the C4 Picasso.  The C4 is in several varieties including the Cactus Hatch, SpaceTourer, and the 7-seat Grand SpaceTourer.

20181213_090149

I know I’m in the minority, but I think this Chevy Cruze wagon looks better than the Cruze hatchback sold in the U.S.  Although it does heavily resemble a Jetta.

20181213_092557

The Kia Cee’d appears to be a Kia Forte with extra cargo room.  The 2018 models are definitely underpowered by American standards with only 118hp, but who doesn’t love a 6-speed manual that’ll get 53mpg?

20181213_090242

The Toyota Hi-Lux has been in production for over 50 years, but never sold in the USA as such, but just as “Toyota Truck” until 1995 when the Tacoma name took over.  It’s a very crude workhorse type of truck with a diesel option that would have issues passing domestic safety and emission standards.  Toyota has sold 12 million worldwide since 1968 and in true Toyota fashion, they have legendary longevity.

20181213_083116

The Nissan X-Trail is a rebadged Rogue.  X-Trail just sounds more off-road capable, right?

mazda6wagonviaautocarupdatesdotcom
photo courtesy of autocarupdates.com

I saw a handful of these Mazda 6 wagons, but only in unfavorable light for picture taking.  The 6 wagon was last sold in the US in 2007.  Dear Mazda, please bring this beauty back!

20181210_095121

This older Toyota Corolla definitely didn’t win any design trophies when it was new and reminded me of an early 1980’s Mazda GLC hatchback.

20181212_091357

The Dacia Duster is a slightly odd, but forgettable design.  The Duster is a joint venture between Renault and their Romanian based subsidiary Dacia.  What was so striking about an otherwise unmemorable vehicle is that this was one of very few vehicles I saw the entire week with noticeable body damage.  Is there a law against driving damaged vehicles in Iceland or are they just very good drivers overall?  From our experience in Iceland, I believe it’s the latter.

Driving in Iceland was enjoyable in spite of the loud metal studded snow tires we had on our rental, but the quality of roads were a night and day improvement over a vast majority of the roads I travel daily at home.

Next week – the year in review!

 

 

2019 Chevrolet Cruze

It’s now or never to make an impression

If you’ve picked up a car magazine in the last few months, you’re probably aware that Ford is getting out of the car business in the U.S. and GM is now focusing (see what I did there?) on crossovers, trucks, and electric cars.  So you’d think that the people at Chevy’s small car division would be putting their best product forward in an attempt to change Mary Barra’s mind about killing off the Cruze.

20181228_182247

Well, the Cruze isn’t the worst thing on 4-wheels, but at the nearly $23,000 price point in this LT trim, it should lean more towards “WOW” than “whatever”.  The base L version has a MSRP of $19,000 minimum and can go over $30K with the 9-speed automatic diesel with a few option packages and accessories.  It’d take A LOT of miles to break even and justify the diesel’s jump in price even with 48MPG highway rating.

20181228_182356

The base 1.4L turbo 4 had a class typical 8 second 0-60 time with a not-so-typical EPA besting 40mpg on the highway on our 225 mile day trip.  I hope the tuners will try to up the boost and make an unsuspecting sleeper pending of course if the engine block can handle it.

20181228_182314

For 2019, the Cruze gets a mild styling refresh to differentiate itself a little more from the slightly larger Malibu, but the similarities are still there.

20181228_182238

I thought the rear end was a little too similar to the Corolla & Sentra.  How about some narrow LED taillights to set it apart?

20181228_182615

The trunk was surprisingly large for a midsize car and even more surprising was the spare tire that has already seen some use.   I didn’t need the trunk at all during my day with the Cruze, so I left it alone.

After I turned it back in, I wonder if a previous renter hadn’t done some damage to the car.  There was a fairly loud ‘clunk’ coming from the rear at take-off that made me suspect that it had sustained some suspension damage that wasn’t visible without being on a lift.

20181228_182302

The dark cloth front seats were comfortable and supportive and I had zero fatigue after 90 straight minutes of driving.  The passenger seat was not power operated and could only go 4 ways manually.

The cabin was quiet even during a brief passing moment of 80mph.  Judge all you want, but I didn’t want to be in the way of a fast approaching fully loaded semi truck.

The handling was pretty good considering the tires could have been better.  They seemed noisier than they should have been on less than perfect road surfaces.  Granted, GM got a gigantic volume discount since that was the standard issue tire across the entire fleet, but I’d be curious to see the difference on a set of high quality Michelins.

20181228_182432

The driver’s seat surround was acceptable at this price point, but the dash and door panels screamed cheap to the touch and the eye.

20181228_182517

Since I’d already driven and scoped out a Malibu and Impala, the radio and HVAC controls needed no learning curve.  It was odd to be in a car so new that there was still a never used radio station preset.  I liked that the USB and power outlet were prominent and not in the center storage compartment.

20181228_182509

On this particular rental I purchased the prepaid gasoline option since the tank was about 3/8 full at pickup and that was exactly the amount I planned on using for the day.  The dashboard went from “53 miles to empty” to “Fuel level low” so I don’t know exactly how close I was cutting it, but I definitely came out ahead since the prepay was 29 cents per gallon less than the pumps in town AND the needle was below obviously below “E”.  It’s a similar feeling when your GPS says “7 hours to destination”, therefore I accept the challenge to make it there in 6 1/2 hours or less.

20181228_182459

The dashboard is an obvious sibling to the Impala and Malibu and just as easy to read at a glance.  The 160mph speedometer is just plain silly.  If this car could reach 125mph on a flat road or even downhill, I’d be very surprised.

Things of note:
Don’t procrastinate if you want one, they probably won’t be around much longer.
EPA states 28City/38Highway and I achieved shocking 40mpg in mostly highway driving.
Would people consider a Trax instead of this?
Buy it? Rent it? Avoid it?
I liked the Cruze ok, but I have a few friends that have had one and they were maintenance and repair nightmares with very few miles.  I wouldn’t bother mentioning that fact if they drove like a Nascar driver, but that’s not the case.  Replacing the radiator once before it hits 100,000 is not ok, but replacing it before 50,000 miles is completely unacceptable.  I’d like to think that was a single model year problem or a bad batch of plastic that had built-in defects.  No way I’d buy a new one, but I’m curious what condition a well-maintained version would be with 75,000+ miles.  Since it was so super efficient and comfortable for two people, I’d rent it again, but only if a similar Corolla wasn’t available to scope out for a day.
Chevy if you’re listening . . .
What will fill the affordable fuel efficiency void if the smallest thing made is a crossover or an expensive hybrid?
On a scale from 1-100: (1- never / 100- now and forever!)
Buy it now – 15
Buy it later at half the current price – 45
F.E.D. (Fun, Efficiency & Desirability) – 50 (file most of those points under ‘efficiency’)
Oooh and ahhh factor – 20
Recommended to rent – 55

RIGHT UNDER THE WIRE before midnight.

Happy New Year! ! ! !

 

 

 

 

2018 Mazda CX-5

Favorite SUV so far?

Mazda’s SkyActiv technology has been around for a while now and the mix of power and fuel economy continues satisfy a lot of buyers in a class that is largely dominated by the Toyota RAV4 and Honda CR-V.

20181223_123127

The 4-cylinder 176hp engine isn’t a rocket ship by any means, but 0-60 to 8.5 seconds is respectable for a SUV that’ll get 30mpg in a mix of city and highway driving.   The 6-speed automatic performed without a hitch under heavy acceleration or casual highway cruising.

20181223_122912

The fuel filler door was unusually large.  When refueling, the option is to put the cap on the what seemed to be a slightly magnetic black pad to the right or hanging it on the metal cradle on the filler door itself.  It seems like a setup for a possible alternative fuel port.  An electric outlet next to a gasoline filler door sounds like a disaster waiting to happen, but maybe it could be for hydrogen or CNG.  More than likely I’m just reading too much into it and it’s just wasted space.

20181223_122922

The rear styling is obvious Mazda since the taillights have the same pointy cat-eye shape as the MX-5 Miata, 3, and 6 models.

20181223_122934

The cargo area swallowed the poinsettia bush (way too big to be called a single ‘plant’) that a friend gave to me after the 4th Sunday of Advent.  Her forever curious dog was at risk of eating some of it and I didn’t know poinsettias can make dogs really sick.  There was no cargo net in sight which is common in most SUVs now, but it is sold as a $60 dealer accessory.

20181223_123051

The front fascia, including the unmistakable grille, shares a lot of styling cues from the rest of the Mazda line.  On a positive note, how could the car overheat with a grille opening that huge?  The small headlights and the huge hood that nearly goes all the way to the fender corners really differentiates the CX-5 from everything else.

20181223_123746

The lane departure warning and traction control buttons are surrounded by. . . 4 blank nothings.  I looked on the Mazda website to see what these blank buttons could be, but what a disappointment to learn that they are also useless blanks on the [supposed] maxed out Grand Touring.  After a little more digging on other Mazda models, the $7,000 less expensive Mazda 3 has the same exact panel.  What’s the point of that since the CX-5 and 3 are manufactured in 2 different places?   I promise I’ll try not to beat a dead horse about blank buttons next year.

20181223_123037

The front seats were very comfortable and looked amazing.  The 2-tone leather and suede looked very expensive and if they age well years down the road, this particular feature should help immensely with future resale value.  My 2 weekend dinner buddies commented this was their favorite vehicle so far mainly attributed to seat comfort.  The rear seats were just as cozy and had the same suede inlay as the fronts.

20181223_123227

The center console was an odd combination of buttons (first Mazda rental so far), but very easy to learn.  The NAV button is misleading as it doesn’t have standard mapped navigation, just a digital compass display.  The sport setting next to the gear shifter just means that in ‘sport mode’ that the transmission only utilizes 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th gears.  I think that’d help on a steep incline to prevent the constant downshifts, but not much use otherwise.  The gear shifter in manual mode would nearly do the same thing.  The mute button on the lower right was useful when talking in the cabin.

20181223_123233

The climate control buttons were perfectly laid out and I wouldn’t change a thing.  Every button did exactly as expected.  The heated seats are a welcome addition to ANY car in December.  The passenger seat sensors were much less sensitive to where I could put a few bags on the seat without the need of a seatbelt to keep the warning chimes off.

20181223_123246

The dashboard display was also excellent.  The fixed speedometer and tachometer were clear and sharp in all lighting and the changeable display on the right was also easy to see in any configuration.  The windshield wiper and headlight stalks contained no surprises either.

20181223_123257

Is it odd to love a steering wheel design?  If so, so be it!  I loved the chrome Mazda logo and the polished aluminum inlay at the bottom.  The steering wheel thickness was confident and comfortable where ever my hands happened to land.  My employer will be relieved to know that I don’t use the horn on every rental, but a cell phone addicted guy in a Chevy Dually prompted me to honk at 55mph.  I had an Integra years ago that had rusted horns that became inoperable shortly after I bought it.  I replaced it with a 3-tone air horn that was so loud, 18-wheelers were confused at what was behind them.  The CX-5 didn’t need an air horn, but I’d prefer one with more volume.

20181223_122948

The CX-5 was all business from the side.  There’s nothing really polarizing about the style except the unusually wide hood, which is neither good or bad nowadays, but it’s difficult to differentiate it from the less expensive CX-3 from any distance.

Things of note:
Entry MSRP is $24,100 for the base sport version, this Touring starts at $2,000 more.
Achieved an impressive 29.9 mpg thanks in part to the 6-speed auto and lighter than normal acceleration.  EPA estimates seem too conservative at  24CITY/30HWY.
A maxed out Grand Touring with every option and accessory is $36,500.
Imagine the fun with a turbo.
Buy it? Rent it? Avoid it?
I don’t have the need or desire to buy a SUV, but this is undoubtedly one of my favorites I’ve ever had the pleasure of riding in or driving – rental or otherwise.  This would be very comfortable for 4 people on a short in-town night out or a cross-country road trip. I’d be fine with being assigned a CX-5 again, although I want to try others in the class first.
Mazda if you’re listening . . .
It’s hard to mess with a good thing, especially since the RAV4 and CR-V engineers are always in the chase, but more than one powertrain should be available.
On a scale from 1-100: (1- never again / 100- every time)
Buy it now – 45
Buy it later at half the current price – 80
F.E.D. (Fun, Efficiency & Desirability) – 55
Oooh and ahhh factor – 45
Recommended to rent – 85

I’ll have one more review before the year end!  Within the next few weeks I’ll be adding “Unusual Cars of Iceland” plus my favorites from 2018.

 

2017 Hyundai Accent

Not the smallest Hyundai

After our Icelandic rental of an i10, I had to scope out an Accent to see how it compared.  This 2017 model (I’ve only seen one 2018 Elantra and have yet to see a 2019 Hyundai of any type in our fleet) was the only Hyundai available and it had over 30,000 miles on the odometer.  It is probably on it’s way to a retail or wholesale lot sooner than later.

20181216_130723

The Accent is one of the few vehicles in our fleet that doesn’t have Bluetooth capability.  Granted, this is a $16,000 car, but Bluetooth should be a pretty inexpensive safety addition just to keep drivers focused on the road instead of a phone.

20181216_130653

Compared to the i10 we had in Iceland, this 4-cylinder 137hp Accent was a rocket ship.  The 6-speed automatic was a much needed while improving fuel economy also.

20181216_130814

The front seats were very similar to the i10 in that they were not very supportive on the lower back.  A long-trip would be very unpleasant even though the highway ride was much better than I thought possible in a car this small.

20181216_130807

Rear seat legroom was night and day different from the i10.  This is supposedly a 5-passenger hatchback, but even 3 teenagers would be snug in the backseat as it is not very wide.  The rear seats were more supportive and comfortable possibly due to lack of use.

20181216_130752

If you had told me the Accent would have a tiny cargo area, I’d immediately have to show you pictures of the i10 trunk!  The Accent’s cargo hold was easily 2 times and probably closer to 3 times bigger.

20181216_130620

The console was very reminisce of the smaller i10, but lacking the extra power outlet for the backseat.  The light color interior has held up remarkable well considering so many rental cars with anything but black cloth or leather show stains nearly immediately.   The gear shifter felt surprisingly firm, but calling it ‘sporty’ would be a stretch; not at all what would be expected in a bare bones econobox.

20181216_130730

The rear end has the distinctive Hyundai tail lights and rear reflectors that are common throughout their fleet.  After driving the Accent in the dreary weather all day, I wonder if any carmaker will figure out how to make the rear windshield wiper obsolete and use wind and aerodynamics to clear the water on the rear glass.

20181216_130612

The center stack was typical except for the recirculate button seemed to be tacked on at the bottom as an afterthought.  The sound system could have been better if the rear speakers had worked, but the bass was impressive coming from only the 2 front speakers.  Purely coincidental that the SiriusXM radio was playing a weather appropriate song.  The Accent has a CD player, but for 2019 a CD Player is no longer available and Bluetooth is standard.

20181216_130450

As shown in the i10 blog last week, it’s 4-speed auto revved at 3000rpm at 90kmh (about 55mph) and the Accent was much better off at only 1800rpm.  The digital center is very sparse as it only 2 trip odometers and fuel economy other than what’s displayed above.

20181216_130902

This particular Accent was missing the antenna add-on that would have helped with radio reception in parking garages, but still worked ok without it.  I’d guess one of the many car washes this Accent has seen took care of that antenna a while ago.

20181216_130711

LED headlights weren’t available on the Accent line in 2017, but standard on the loaded Limited trim for 2019.

Things of note:
No Bluetooth capability.
EPA states 26City/36Highway and I achieved an expected 29 in mostly city driving.
More than double the horsepower of the i10 and only weighs 500lbs more.
Buy it? Rent it? Avoid it?
The much improved Yaris and the class leading (according to some co-workers) Focus are night and day better than the Accent.  The Yaris is much more comfortable and the Focus’s we have in our fleet are mostly the Titanium loaded trim level.  That might be why the Accent’s are being phased out and not replaced as the company appears to be upgrading the segment’s class.
Hyundai if you’re listening . . .
Regardless of price, this is as small as necessary for the USA.  Please leave the i10 to the Europeans.
On a scale from 1-100: (1- nay / 100- yay)
Buy it now – 20
Buy it later at half the current price – 35
F.E.D. (Fun, Efficiency & Desirability) – 35
Oooh and ahhh factor – 30
Recommended to rent – 30

2018 Chevrolet Camaro

For the driver and a friend. . . only ONE friend

20181222_101045

Before you think, WOW!  What was the Camaro ZL1 like?  The base Camaro doesn’t have anywhere near 455hp like the ZL1, but it was a capable performer even with ‘only’ 275hp.  Even so, it wasn’t too shabby with the accelerator.

20181222_101120

The little 2.0L turbo 4 was anxious to go at the slightest tap of the gas pedal, but the exhaust note had no hint of the desired V8 growl.  It actually sounded so poor that I wondered if the car didn’t already have an exhaust system leak.  There’s PLENTY of space between the engine block and the grille for a bigger turbo or any list of mods.

I asked my friend in the backseat,

“how’s the seats back there?”

Without hesitation she said “It sucks!  If I was an animal, I’d be a turtle and just stay in my shell!”

20181222_100941

The front passenger and I laughed of course, but after closer inspection, I felt a little guilty having both of my 5’7″ friends in either seat.  The front passenger seat was tight with the power seat up about half way to allow minimal leg room in the back.

20181222_100951

My driver’s seat was back almost all the way which left less than 2″ of legroom for a poor soul that would have been behind me.  Needless to say, this is really only meant for 2 front seat occupants.  Even an infant car seat would be a difficult squeeze in the back.

20181222_100852

The rear view highlights the wide body and narrow cabin.  Outward visibility from all angles is horrible, but as they say “If you are going fast enough, you only need to be aware of what’s in front”.  The base Camaro looks pretty good for a sub-$30,000 coupe, but it’s definitely a mild toned-down version of the much more in-demand V-8s.  Since this Camaro is so stripped down, maybe Chevy views it as a blank slate for the customers that want the endless add-on and customization possibilities.

20181222_101021I’m surprised that halogen headlights are still the standard and not the more modern LED or Xenon bulbs, but halogen blends with the retro styled center console.

20181222_100757

There was very little storage space in the Camaro.  The center console has capacity for some spare change, a phone, a phone charger, and some fast food napkins but that’s about it.  Only two cupholders in the entire cabin would leave the backseat passengers to holding their drinks for the trip duration.

20181222_100813

I liked what Chevy did with the retro styled vents, but they scored a big fat zero on practicality of the rest of the controls.  The temperature is controlled by the left metal trim surround and the fan speed is controlled by the right, but the fan speed dial doesn’t work when the defrost setting is on.  It seems you are at the mercy of the auto setting until you change the setting to ‘face’ or ‘foot’.  I fiddled with it at several stoplights, but it was unnecessarily frustrating to figure it out completely.  The rest of the climate control buttons were also very small and only lit by a tiny amber light.  It’d be very difficult to see what was activated in direct sunlight.  The standard issue 6-speaker stereo was very good and here’s an odd trick that improved it.  I lowered the power seat enough to where my knee wasn’t blocking the door speaker resulting in a drastic improvement of sound quality.  That was a strange first!

20181222_100902

The driver’s seat was comfortable on my legs, lower back, and my sides.  As you can see in the picture, there was a strange crease in the seat bottom fabric that wasn’t on the passenger seat.  I can’t comprehend how that could happen without having permanent internal damage.  Did something collapse in there?  Someone enlighten me!

20181222_100739

Compared to many of the other cars I’ve rented this year, the Camaro was one of the few that could actually get use from the steering wheel paddle shifters.  It’s a big no-no to track a rental car, but at least laps around a track would make sense in this [albeit] automatic Camaro vs. the Continental of a few months ago.  Also an oddity, I think the 4-cyl turbo could get near that 160mph speedometer maximum.  The 125mph (200kmh) speedometer maximum on last weeks Hyundai i10 would have been a terrifying experience.

 

20181222_100843

The trunk opening was miniscule also.  I’m sure the wasted space setup is for the optional convertible top, but it’s really pointless to have so much covered dead air below the trunk hinges.

20181222_100806-1

The traction control defeat and ‘Mode’ buttons for the Touring/Track/Ice-Snow settings was prominently placed like drivers would change that regularly.  Maybe for the SS or ZL1 models, but I think that’s lost on the target market 4-cylinder crowd.

We all know someone that had a maintenance nightmare 3rd generation Camaro and time will tell if the 2018 models will be the same or better.  I’m anxious to hear repair histories of the 5th and 6th generations after 120,000 miles of daily use.

Things of note:
MSRP starts at about $26,700 for the base 4-cyl.
Achieved an impressive 26.9 mpg thanks to the 8-speed auto. EPA says 22CITY/31HWY.
Top shelf ZL1 convertible easily can reach $75,000.
Imagine the fun at 400 fewer pounds.
Buy it? Rent it? Avoid it?
Not even when I was 16 years old was a Camaro on my wish list of first cars.  Granted, when I was 16, the 3rd generation F body was selling like crazy, but I never had a poster in my bedroom.  I’d rent one again, but only if I had no chance of having any people in the back seat.  Plus, I have yet to test out the 2-door Mustang or Q60.  There’s so many choices of 275hp vehicles that are bigger, sound better, more comfortable, and equally fun to drive to recommend buying one.  I understand that Chevy’s target audience is most interested in the name badge and 50+ year heritage.
Chevy if you’re listening . . .
How much weight could be saved if this was a 2-seater?
On a scale from 1-100: (1- nay / 100- yay)
Buy it now – 25
Buy it later at half the current price – 45
F.E.D. (Fun, Efficiency & Desirability) – 75
Oooh and ahhh factor – 40
Recommended to rent – 55

2018 Hyundai i10

Even smaller than it sounds

I had an amazing vacation to Iceland and this was our rental for the week.  Thankfully there was only 3 of us because the car was stuffed to the gills with 3 suitcases and 3 passengers.  I know all the pictures look like they were taken at sunrise or sunset, but this time of year, Iceland only gets a little over 4 hours of sun per day and we saw direct sun very little all week.  Add a mix of clouds and precipitation, and it looks like either early evening or 2am all the time.

20181212_091424

It’s tiny in every regard except the front legroom, but that’s only if the seats are all the way back leaving only several inches of legroom for the [hopefully] petite passengers in the backseat.

20181214_062053

I don’t think a car like this would fly at all in the US as the only attraction would be the price.  Size wise, the smart car is the only thing comparable, but it’s a 2-seater.  The prices of these start at 2.190.000 Icelandic Krona . . . translating to about US$18,000.  I talked with a local briefly about cars and he said that all autos are roughly double the price from the US.  That makes sense since this is one class smaller than the domestic Accent.  If you want a fairly common Hyundai SUV found here in the states, the base price of a Hyundai Santa Fe is $64,700 in Iceland.  Needless to say, every large vehicle on the road looked out of place!

20181214_062456

I don’t think it’s a horrible looking vehicle, but it definitely wouldn’t be on my short list to purchase either.

20181213_074129

Primarily the reason not to purchase is pictured here.  Powering the i10 is a 3-cylinder 66hp engine with a 4-speed transmission.  Luckily, it weighs just shy of 2100 lbs.  Hyundai’s primary focus was obviously the low-as-possible MSRP.  The jaunt from 0-60 can be an intimidating process if you are trying to merge into one of the many round-a-bouts in Iceland, but thankfully most of the other cars on the road are also tiny and slow.  I found a range of 0-60 times anywhere from 12.6 to 16.0 seconds, but I’d estimate the 0-60 was in the 14 second range as I can’t find an accurate count anywhere on the web in English at least.  It became clear at our first gas station fill up why smaller is definitely better since the only gasoline choice is 95-octane (!) and it’s about $6.70 per gallon.  The commonplace state-side Ford F-series trucks, Escalades, and V8 powered sports cars that we’re accustomed to are very rare.

20181214_071144

At about 55mph, the tiny 1.0liter is pumping out 3000 rpm, which translated to an abysmal 33.3mpg overall for our week with the A10.  The mileage was so low that I questioned if the tank was full when we got it, but the gas gauge looked identical at pick-up time and drop off.  Most of the mileage was from highway driving to the touristy stuff, so getting to 40mpg would seem to be a challenge.

20181212_091501

The ride wasn’t as bad as expected even with the loud studded snow tires.  I’m sure it’s a requirement of some type either mandated by the government or rental car agency that certain months of the year all cars need to have these installed.  My state of Kentucky allows unrestricted use of these road damaging tires, but 10 states don’t allow them at all and the rest have seasonal restrictions.  Luckily, the roads in Iceland were very smooth and well maintained.

20181214_062147

The dash was very well laid out and crystal clear, but it’s very generic.  A dearly departed friend from high school had an early 90’s Geo Metro for several years and similarities between the two were borderline comical.  It’d be very easy to complain about everything the Hyundai was lacking, but simplicity is probably best when driving in a foreign country.

20181214_062241

In a normal array of buttons and tech found in between the 2 front seats, all the i10 has is an extra power outlet.

20181214_062233

The stereo was bare bones and no CD player or satellite radio either, but there was an unusual number of radio stations and 103.9 FM was an especially good one.  They played music on there that I hadn’t heard in years and missed hearing.  A very pleasant surprise was the heated front seats.  A huge disappointment was the lack of A/C.  There’s probably only a handful of days where cooling the inside of a car is necessary, but on more than one occasion we needed it to defog the windows.  The windows eventually cleared every time, but we were baking in the cabin until the inner glass was warm enough not to have inside condensation.  Use of an a/c compressor would have removed the moisture without baking the passengers.  We only saw snow 1 day and it was in the mid-30’s to high-40’s the rest of the time we were there.  Aside from the day of bone chilling 50mph winds(!) it wasn’t the stereotypical trip to the far north Atlantic.  Besides the auto transmission, I’d confidently say that heated seats were the only option on this car.

20181214_062114

The driver’s seat was only tolerable for short trips.  There was zero lumbar support and the only useful adjustment was the recline, which would intrude noticeably to anyone in the back seat if the driver was over 6 feet tall.  The steering wheel mute button for the stereo was useful and unusual in the other rental cars of this size I’ve seen.

20181214_062011

When we picked up the car, the data sheet said room for 4 adults and 1 suitcase.  I thought it was a joke, but we instantly learned that it was indeed a single suitcase trunk.  After adding a small backpack to the right, the trunk was as full as possible.  This car would have been impossible with 4 adults + luggage.

This rental car and trip in general was proof positive that Americans are definitely obsessed with bigger vehicles than necessary.

Things of note:
Huge difference in performance with extra passengers and luggage
66hp for a 4-wheeled passenger car would NEVER be ok stateside
It’s lacking a lot, but you get what you pay for.

Buy it? Rent it? Avoid it?
If I ever had the need to move overseas, the i10 would be near the bottom of my shopping list.  It’s borderline acceptable if you never plan to have passengers or the slightest inkling of cargo, but how can any car buyer guarantee that?  I’d be curious to see what the gas mileage would be on a 5-speed manual.  Even if money is tight, I’d opt for a larger rental or a used car purchase that has a little more oomph.
Hyundai if you’re listening . . .
The company must be doing something right because the i10, i20, and i30’s were all over Reykjavik, but a 6-speed manual or automatic would do wonders for fuel economy and performance.
On a scale from 1-100: (1- nay / 100- yay)
Buy it now – 10
Buy it later at half the current price – 20
F.E.D. (Fun, Efficiency & Desirability) – 15
Oooh and ahhh factor – 40 (due to it’s perplexing small size to this foreigner)
Recommended to rent – 30

 

2019 Jeep Compass Trailhawk

Shortest review Ever

As I mentioned in my Highlander review, this was my first assigned vehicle of the day that was an unbelievable disappointment at start-up.

20181201_171819
I was on my way to a friend’s house for a dinner date and I got this tiny Jeep for 3 people.  Just two miles later, I returned it.  The cabin was tiny, the engine was loud and weak, plus the transmission was jerky when downshifting AND upshifting.

20181201_171849

To pour salt on the wounds, the base price of these is over $28,000.

Base price!

That type of cabin noise is only acceptable and expected for a car at half the price.

20181201_172000

It’s only redeeming quality was the interior where I expect is the reason for the inflated price.  The seats were black with red piping and stitching accents that looked great.

I may try a similarly classed Cherokee in the future, but no way I’d rent a Compass again if I was going to have even 1 extra passenger at any time.  If I hear enough outcry, I may try it again if I’m going solo throughout the rental.

2019 Toyota Highlander

You get what you pay for(?)

I initially rented a Jeep Compass Trailhawk for the day, but after driving it only 2 miles, I immediately went back in for an exchange.  More on that in a later [abbreviated] review.

20181202_112251

At first glance on the side, it slight resembles a Grand Cherokee.  I think that’s in part due to Jeep has a similar styled wheel and the oddly distinctive rear tail light.

20181202_112231

But the front is all Highlander.  When I first sat down in the driver’s seat, it was apparent that this was much closer to the base model than the fully optioned one.  The blacked out spots for the non-existent fog lights could have been made a little smoother.  The rounded center inset piece is even shaped like a light bulb.

highlanderblanks

This isn’t exactly an interior picture that would be in 2019 Highlander literature.  I think the only thing that could compare would be an old Ford Cargo Van with an am/fm radio surrounded by blanks.  Both of those just look awful and screams cheap.  I don’t think that’s appropriate for ANY vehicle that costs nearly $35 grand.

20181202_112307

I see the styling cues to the RAV4, but the Highlander is noticeably much larger.

20181202_111901

With the backseats folded down, the Highlander could be a viable option to Santa’s sleigh.  The Sienna would be only marginally bigger in available cubic feet of storage.

20181202_111836

With the 3-person backrow seats up, I think 3 teenagers would be comfortable back there as long as the middle row seats were moved up a little.  But if 7 passengers and the driver were making a multi-state trip, the Sienna would definitely be the better choice.

20181202_112135

The 295hp 8-speed automatic performed well although at 25mph, the transmission seemed unsure whether or not to downshift 1 or 2 gears.  It was acceptable, but it was not nearly as smooth as the Kia Optima (did I just say that?) from last week.  But with those 2 extra gears, the much bigger and heavier Highlander can deliver nearly 30mpg on the highway.

20181202_112408

The center stack is reminiscent of the Camry from a few months ago, but the sound system was a such a disappointment that even the $19000 Sentra tops it performance and sound quality.  According to Toyota’s website, there’s 5 different variations of Entune and JBL stereos available for the Highlander.  The one on this 2300-mile example was the base Entune with only 6 speakers with the top shelf JBL units have 12 speakers.  As a testament to the width of the 8-seat Highlander, I immediately noticed that the tune knob was a long arm stretch from the driver’s seat.

20181202_112456

The larger than normal steering wheel buttons were welcomed after several recent vehicles had a less intuitive layout.  Adaptive cruise control is standard, but can be defeated if the ‘cruise on’ button is pushed in and held for 2 seconds.

20181202_112444

The dashboard is bare bones with only a narrow changeable screen in the center.  The trip computers relating to gasoline usage were spot on accurate.

20181202_112429

Hidden down below the USB, aux, and 12v outlets is the traction control defeat button and other weather driving assist buttons.

20181202_093451

I’d never seen a pass thru shelf for plugging in electronics for a passenger vehicle, but here it is! There was plenty of space on this shelf that went from the gear shifter to the passenger door for 4 devices to sit and charge or for simultaneous aux port sound system use.  I wonder how long the plastic cover will last in rentals before it disappears forever?

20181202_093511

The center console could store more than enough snacks for a week long trip.  Toyota measures it at 24.5 liters or nearly 6 1/2 gallons.  There’s another 12V plug in and the tray is movable back and forth.

20181202_111947

The middle row seats were spacious and the seats were comfortable, but lacking in the thigh support.

I’ve been exposed to previous model year Highlanders from a volunteer job I had a few years ago.  I would drive a 2012 Highlander Hybrid up to 300 miles in a day and it never had a hiccup.  I’m no longer associated with that organization, but when I left 2 years ago it had 210,000 miles and still going strong.  They also had a base 2013 Highlander that had about half as many miles, but still ran like a top.

I see no indication why this 2019 model would not have a different long-term outlook as far as build quality to any previous Highlanders.  Why would Toyota mess with a good thing?

Things of note:
MSRP starts at $34,500 for the base AWD V6.
Achieved a predictable 22.9 mpg. The EPA says 20CITY/29HWY.
Top shelf Limited trims can reach $50,000 with minimal additional options.
295hp is a fair medium for fuel economy and power.
Buy it? Rent it? Avoid it?
I know more than a few people that have early generation Highlanders and they are top tier when it comes to reliability.  300,000 miles is not uncommon on a 2005 with plenty of life still left to go and not even an oil leak.  I’d expect the same from this generation, but the hybrid battery is always hit or miss depending on driving conditions and climate.  I’d rent a Highlander again when hauling a lot of cargo or 6 other passengers, but first, I want to scope out and compare the Pathfinder and Explorer that are in this class also.
Toyota if you’re listening . . .
These seem to be the king of longevity in this class and it’s very telling when looking at prices of comparible used SUV’s with over 100K miles.  How difficult would it be to get an ultra-efficient diesel to the American market?   I hope for the 2020 models and beyond that SiriusXm will be standard in every vehicle.  I’ve recently been in various Yaris, Corolla, Camry, RAV4 models, and now a Highlander that didn’t even have satellite radio available.
On a scale from 1-100: (1- nay / 100- yay)
Buy it now – 55
Buy it later at half the current price – 80
F.E.D. (Fun, Efficiency & Desirability) – 40
Oooh and ahhh factor – 30
Recommended to rent – 75

2018 Kia Optima

Forgettable, in [almost] every way

20181201_104532

Not exactly a duet you’d want to hear the late Natalie Cole do with her dad, but that’s the first impression the Optima left on me.  When I first sat down in the driver’s seat on a dreary Friday afternoon, I thought, “Wow, no way this thing costs over $25,000”.  After a little research I learned this was the bare bones “FE” model (iron Optima for the Chemists on here?).  It had no power seats, no sunroof, nor new tech stuff other than lane change assist (LCA) notifying the driver of approaching cars on either side.

The first impression wasn’t good to say the least, but after a “spirited” quick downhill entrance to the interstate, it grew on me a little.  It’s road manners were very similar to the 2018 Camry from a few months ago, but with a little less maneuverability on the corners.

The 185hp 4-cyl was surprisingly adequate for it’s 3200lb curb weight and I wouldn’t change a thing about the 6-speed automatic.  There’s an optional 7-speed DSG transmission, but that is only for the LX 1.6 liter turbo versions.  Oddly enough, the ‘upgraded’ 1.6 liter engine has 7 fewer horsepower and base price is $1800 more, but fuel economy improves by 4mpg city and 3mpg highway.

20181201_104504

The light color interior of this example has seen better days in it’s 25,000 miles, but thankfully light colored interiors are soon to be a thing of the past in our fleets worldwide.  Make way for the black leather seats in most vehicles in the next model year.  The seats were only ok for comfort since there’s only 6-way manual adjustment options and a 2-way power lumbar.

20181201_104656

It’s hard to believe unless you see it for yourself!  The big lever on top moves the seat up and down, the smaller one behind it reclines the seat up and down, and the little button below and in between is the power lumbar.  That’s right, to move the seats back and forth it’s necessary to lift up the metal bar below your knees and do a sit-down version of the Boot Scootin’ Boogie to move the seat forward, but the lumbar is power operated.  That’ll just be one of those “why on earth” questions for a Kia engineer.

20181201_104609

The trunk was a good size at 15.9 cubic feet, but easily more if the collapsible rear seats were utilized.  There was a very dim trunk light and the 40% left and 60% right side seat releases.  The recent Impala and Maxima really spoiled me on sound deadening in the trunk as rear tire and road noise was noticeably louder in this Kia.

20181201_104521

The back seats were very basic with no extra lighting or even rear facing A/C vents, but I thought the contrasting light and dark colors looked pretty good.

20181201_103857

Below the a/c vent was only 1 of 2 blank buttons in the car, which is a small miracle since this is the base model.  As I was driving to return the Kia, the LCA system was beeping incessantly because I had my left turn signal on, but I was slowly approaching a stoplight.  There was another car approaching in the turn lane to the left of me setting off the warning.  That’s not the worst thing in the world, but could get annoying if you do a lot of downtown big city commuting.  If it gets to be too much, there’s a clearly label defeat button above the fuel release.

20181201_103928

The center stack was well labeled and pretty basic.  I was surprised how sensitive the sensor were in the passenger seat.  I had maybe 4 lbs. of  yoga clothes and towels and the chimes wanted me to buckle up, so I did.  I know my readers will rest easy tonight knowing my sweaty wet clothes and towels were safely buckled in.  At engine start up, the default screen changed from the SiriusXM favorites to the above screen.  That didn’t seem practical as I don’t think many people want to set up options or add a phone every time they got in the car.  I really liked the options of the A/c controls with the clear labeled face only / face and feet / feet only / defrost buttons vs. the ‘mode’ button that seems to becoming more commonplace.

20181201_105709

I have the worst luck EVER when it comes to getting good windshield wiper blades.  That’s why I instantly noticed the Optima had the best windshield wipers EVER!  The blades were flawless (must have been nearly new) and the motor was even super quiet.  I could write a separate blog about wiper blades with all the brands I’ve tried.

20181201_103918

The center console area was generic as it was just hard plastics, but the opening to the right of the gear shifter was perfect for a phone.  The cubby above the gear shifter was perfectly labeled for the USB, aux, and 12V outlets.  Why do so many manufacturers think it’s needed to keep these hidden and unlabeled?  The drive mode defaulted to standard at engine start up and could be changed to ‘sport’ or ‘eco’.  I used eco just once since it seemed like I was pulling a 5th wheel when activated.

20181201_103841

As if we needed more proof that steering wheel buttons are the wave of the future, the Optima FE has 8 buttons and 4 up & down switches on the wheel.  The 4 analog gauges and center digital screen were very easy to read in all light, but the trip computer and fuel economy took some trial and error to display.  The windshield wiper stalk was brilliant.  The delay wiper setting was displayed on the front as far as short or long delay, but was adjustable in the front or the back of the switch.  That made it much easier to grasp with my thumb and forefinger to set it right the first time.

This is a tough class to compete in and every carmaker has to put their best foot forward to even get noticed, much less excel.  The Optima was competent, but except for the unique ignition off/exit music, I won’t remember much about it next month.  BUT . . .

4.1.2

. . . after typing 1200+ words about the Optima, I’m reminded how far it has come in barely over a decade!

Things of note:
MSRP can go as high as $37K for the plug-in hybrid.  This sits at a tad over $22,500.
Achieved a typical 29 mpg within the EPA stated 25CITY/35HWY.

Buy it? Rent it? Avoid it?
The Optima could be the perfect incognito vehicle.  This base model doesn’t do anything particularly well, it doesn’t have polarizing style at any angle (but at least it has SOME styling compared to the sterile 2005 model), but that doesn’t matter to most Kia buyers.  I hope I can meet an Optima owner and ask them, “why did you choose it?”  That conversation would likely end instantly with “price”, but I’m curious to know if it’s more than that.  I’m fully aware I’m in the 1% of the population that is car obsessed and the vast majority of car buyers and renters only care about the name plate, 4 wheels, and a good heater & air conditioner.  The Optima is a fine choice for those that can’t tell the difference between a Camry, Malibu, Accord, Fusion, Sonata, [Mazda]6, and Legacy.  If the pricing is right, get a smokin’ hot deal on a demonstrator model and you’d probably be satisfied for 100K miles.  I wouldn’t rent the Optima again unless a 245hp SX model was available.
Kia if you’re listening . . .
The Sportswagon sold overseas looks great and wouldn’t be a huge seller here, but that could be a cult-like vehicle with a K900 engine and 19″ wheels.  What Kia from the past has been a ‘must have’?
On a scale from 1-100: (1- never again / 100- every time)
Buy it now – 25
Buy it later at half the current price – 85
F.E.D. (Fun, Efficiency & Desirability) – 30
Oooh and ahhh factor – 25
Recommended to rent – 55

 

 

2018 Chevrolet Impala

More 1996 Lincoln Town Car than 1996 Chevy Impala

This weeks ride was initially a let down, but I’m happy to report I liked it more than I thought I would.  I headed down to Georgia for a quick holiday visit with mom and my brother and my first choice of chariots was a Toyota Avalon.  Mom is still debating (5 years and counting) on replacing her ’05 Camry.  No Avalons were in sight at pickup time, so a co-worker graciously retrieved this beauty from another lot where it was on hold as a ‘stand-by’ for one of our satellite locations.

20181125_142152

This is the “Premiere” trim level and it’s maxed out as far as options go for any Impala in 2018.  The front leather seats were top tier and adjustable to fit anyone of any height or weight. 20181125_142608

I really liked the mocha colored piping and stitching that was an extremely well done accent color in an otherwise complete black interior.  It was easily spacious enough for 5 adults.

20181125_142632

The front seats could have used a few more lumbar positions, but were fine during my longest stretch of 300 mile non-stop driving.  The floormats felt super cheap and thin.  No doubt they were the rental car fleet specials.

20181125_142552

The center console was a big hit with mom and the blazing fast heated seats.  A carmaker would be golden if they could figure out how to heat the cabin as fast as these seats warmed up!  I really liked the dark gray/black wood trimmed inlays in the console and door area leading me to believe this color scheme could be ready for ‘black car’ sedan service in a fleet of limos.  I didn’t try the manual transmission setting.  The hidden compartment above the gear shifter features wireless charging.  My old LG phone isn’t compatible, but I think that will be standard issue in nearly all cars in a few years.

20181125_142428

The 18.8 cu ft trunk could easily swallow bags for 5 adult passengers, but a full-size baby stroller would be snug.  The trunk lining/insulation was a little loose so the trunk light on was visible through the crack pictured above.  I noticed the light was mounted and wired onto the top of the lining.  I hope that light never gets too hot!

20181125_142716

The V6 engine and 6-speed automatic were a good match for the Impala.   The blend of power and fuel economy worked well for a car of this size and weight.  I tried for the first time ever E85 gasoline.  I was curious on how proportional the price per gallon savings would be to miles per gallon and if it had an effect on performance.  On my first tank of regular gas (at the start of rental) I achieved 30.6 MPG and on the way back home the trip computer said I was less than 30 miles to empty.  At that point I filled up with E85 and I got 27.8 MPG.  Roughly 10% less efficiency and exactly 10% less cost.  It wasn’t long ago that the cost of E85 was a full 30% less here locally, so the need for alternative fuel is lost on me at this point.   Unless the price of E85 nosedives again, I’d honestly rather just use regular gas and have fewer pit stops.

20181125_142527

The dashboard is unmistakably Chevy.  According to Chevy’s website, peak power comes at 6800RPM, but doesn’t indicate what is redline.  I thought it was odd that the Pacifica of last week didn’t have a redline on the RPM gauge either.  It’s probably never a question with the Pacifica or Impala target audience, but I’m always curious about how far a vehicle can be pushed.  I thought I had a ‘me-only’ gripe about the Impala’s odd steering wheel, but after talking with a competing rental agent, he had the same complaint also.  When I’m highway cruising, my right hand is in the 4 o’clock position while resting on the armrest.  But after only about 100 miles, my hand was getting cramped and I was having to change driving positions frequently with both hands.  It looks like a normal steering wheel, so all I can figure is that the spoke spacing or steering wheel thickness just doesn’t work well with my hands

20181125_142534

The center stack shared of lot of cues from the much lesser Malibu, but with a few appearance upgrades.  Mom (and I for that matter) were very impressed by the LED trim around the dash and the doors when the headlights were on.  She was also impressed with the separate climate controls for the driver and passenger.  I got a kick out of that because that’s standard issue in many cars of several classes, but compared to her 13 year old Camry, that’s notable!  I know die-hard audiophiles aren’t typically fans of Bose products, but the standard stereo in the Premiere trim was excellent at all volumes for music and talk radio.

20181125_142207

LED daytime running lamps are on each side of the bottom grille, which appear to be able to house fog lights.  LED’s are an upgrade from regular incandescent bulbs on the lower trims.

20181125_142136

The “Premiere” and “V6” logos on the trunk are the only things that differentiate this from the less optioned Impalas at this angle.  Again, a lot of Malibu styling influence from this view.

The ride was excellent and the suspension hid road flaws like a boss, but handling was not as I expected and ‘floaty’ like an old Lincoln Town Car.  The Maxima from 2 weeks ago set the bar really high in cornering for this class in our fleet.  But high performance cornering isn’t an issue if the primary mode of travel is cruising down the interstate at 85 MP . . . I mean 70MPH.

Things of note:
MSRP sits at a tad over $38,500.
Odd at this price point not to have memory seats as standard.
Achieved an impressive 28.9 mpg.  The EPA states 19CITY/28HWY.
305 hp was enjoyable, the 198hp in the lesser trims would probably be unpleasant and the fuel economy difference is negligible.
Buy it? Rent it? Avoid it?
If I had a job that required an American company car, this would be definitely be in the running.  If said job required a lot of highway driving with passengers, the Impala would be on near the top of the list.  I’m curious what the 2.5 liter 4-cyl Impalas are like, but 107 fewer horsepower would be a huge letdown after driving the V6.  I imagine it’d be a similar experience to the disappointing LaCrosse of a few weeks ago. I’d rent an Impala again for a multi-state trip, but would opt for the similarly classed Maxima for city driving.  Bose has come through with a stellar sound system.
Chevy if you’re listening . . .
Just this week everyone learned of the Impala getting the ax next year.  Since the similar Taurus is getting chopped at Ford also, what will fill the void for those buyers who don’t like SUVs?  Good call on dumping the overpriced Lacrosse, but I think sending the Impala to the grave is a mistake.
On a scale from 1-100: (1- overdue to die Mrs. Barra / 100- big mistake Mrs. Barra)
Buy it now – 35
Buy it later at half the current price – 65
F.E.D. (Fun, Efficiency & Desirability) – 30
Oooh and ahhh factor – 40
Recommended to rent – 75